Good points - I guess I see this more as something I'd be able to put on quickly (since the drying time is super fast) and then dash out the door. More of a one-night polish, I suppose. It really didn't get rubbery until I was in the shower, and I'm guessing it wouldn't have done that if I'd applied top and bottom coats.

Also as someone whose polish chips within a day or two no matter what, I don't mind that this isn't long-lasting. It's much gentler on my nails than having all those chemicals on them (which usually cause my nails to get really soft and peely).

I do agree, though, that this product won't suit everyone!